Frequently Asked Questions

What is an Earth-friendly diet?

Why is the Center for Biological Diversity focusing on reducing meat consumption?

Why do I have to eat less meat so other people can have lots of kids or drive gas-guzzlers?

Is this really as important as other issues, like climate change or endangered species protection?

Aren’t vegetarian diets high in soy and processed foods bad for the environment, too?

Isn’t organic, grass-fed, free-range meat better for the environment than factory farm meat?

What about eating eggs and dairy?

What about eating fish?
Are some types of fish more sustainable to eat than others?

What about food waste?

How will I get enough protein if I start eating more meatless meals?

How do I get started changing my diet?

 

Q: What is an Earth-friendly diet?

Our food choices don’t just have an impact on our own health, but also on the health of the planet and other species. Meat production is one of the most environmentally damaging systems in the world, a major contributor to habitat loss, resource depletion, pollution and climate change. You can take steps toward an Earth-friendlier diet by eating less or no meat. You have at least three chances a day to make a difference for the environment: Choose to take extinction off your plate.

 

Learn more about the impact of meat production on the environment.

 

Q: Why is the Center for Biological Diversity focusing on reducing meat consumption?

When it comes to the causes of environmental destruction and overconsumption of resources, the meat industry is at the top of the list. Meat production uses massive amounts of water and land, and leaves behind devastating amounts of pollution and greenhouse gases. America’s livestock industry — particularly through grazing on public lands — is one of the greatest threats to endangered species and habitat.

 

The United States consumes more meat than almost any other nation in the world. Every meal is an opportunity to reduce our environmental footprint, and by choosing to eat less meat, we can choose a healthier future for wildlife, the planet and people. Take our Earth-friendly Diet Pledge now.

 

Q: Why do I have to eat less meat so other people can have lots of kids or drive gas-guzzlers?

Many environmentalists underestimate the impact of reducing meat consumption. Nearly 60 percent of the carbon footprint of the average American diet comes from animal products, and meat is responsible for land degradation, water pollution, and the direct endangerment and death of wildlife.

 

Climate change, water scarcity, deforestation, pollution and species extinction are problems that affect all of us. We’re each responsible for our own environmental footprint, but it’s also important to live by example and help educate those around us on how to live more sustainably.

 

Check out our 12 Ways to Live More Sustainably.

 

Q: Is this really as important as other issues, like climate change or endangered species protection?

Meat consumption is a major driver of climate change, the extinction crisis and many other environmental problems. Animal agriculture accounts for at least 14.5 percent — and, according to some studies, as much as 51 percent — of greenhouse gas emissions (more than cars, trains and airplanes combined). From growing feed crops to livestock grazing to handling the 500 million tons of manure generated by U.S. livestock each year, meat production destroys natural habitat and ecosystems at an alarming rate. And wildlife also pays a direct price in order to protect the meat industry’s profits: Whether they pose a potential threat of preying on herds or eating livestock feed, native species are routinely killed by Big Ag, often in great numbers and ruthlessly.

 

Q: Aren’t vegetarian diets high in soy and processed foods bad for the environment, too?

Highly processed food products, including soy, do have a negative impact on the environment. Soybean plantations are responsible for deforestation, soil erosion and pesticide runoff, all of which threaten wildlife habitat and biodiversity. In some cases the carbon cost is also high as the soybeans travel from the plantations to processing centers to your grocery store. All of these environmental costs apply to meat as well, and tend to be much higher for producing animal protein than plant protein. In addition, the vast majority of soybean crops are grown for animal feed, not direct human consumption, so eating less meat will ultimately lessen the impact of soy on the planet, too.

 

It can be misleading to compare a plant-based diet high in soy to a meat-based diet from local, organic sources. When all things are equal — for example, comparing locally sourced meat to locally sourced vegetables — the meatless options come out far ahead for the environment and wildlife. Bottom line: The most Earth-friendly diet is plant-based from local, organic whole foods.

 

Q: Isn’t organic, grass-fed, free-range meat better for the environment than factory farm meat?

While “grass-fed” beef is arguably more humane for livestock animals and doesn’t produce the massive manure pits and runoff found at factory farms or CAFOs (concentrated animal feeding operations), it isn’t as sustainable for wildlife or the planet as many people believe, especially when the need to feed a human population of billions is taken into account. By destroying vegetation, damaging wildlife habitats and disrupting natural processes, livestock grazing wreaks ecological havoc on riparian areas, rivers, deserts, grasslands and forests alike — causing significant harm to species and the ecosystems on which they depend. And the diets of many “grass-fed” herds are often supplemented with water-intensive crops like alfalfa. Studies have also shown that grass-fed cattle emit more methane than those raised on grain feed.

 

There are many important reasons to support local agriculture, but replacing meat one day per week with plant-based food saves more greenhouse gas emissions than eating an entirely local diet that includes meat.

 

There are simply too many people eating too much meat for any form of meat production to be considered sustainable. As population and demand continue to grow — while our natural resources dwindle — the only way to protect the environment and wildlife is to dramatically reduce meat consumption.

 

Q: What about eating eggs and dairy?

All animal products have significant environmental footprints. Whether a cow is raised for hamburgers or dairy, or a chicken for meat or eggs, the animal still requires land, feed and water, and produces emissions and waste. Instead of replacing one animal product with another, we encourage people to choose plant-based alternatives.

 

Q: What about eating fish?

Although many people don’t consider fish to be a type of meat, when it comes to food with negative impacts on the environment and wildlife, reducing seafood needs to be part of the equation to “take extinction off your plate.” Overfishing has depleted many marine species, like bluefin tuna, to the point of imperilment, putting fragile ocean ecosystems at risk. The unintentional capture of species — known as “bycatch” — is a major threat to marine life, including sharks and loggerhead and leatherback sea turtles.

 

Meanwhile, fish farms are just another form of feedlot, with many of the same problems seen in livestock factory farms. Farmed fish are fed wild fish, so they are closely tied to the ocean ecosystem. Fish farms are also a source of degraded habitat from dredging and drilling; water pollution from feces and chemicals; and invasive species when farmed fish escape their cages.

 

Learn more about the Center’s fisheries campaign and join the Bluefin Boycott.

 

Q: Are some types of fish more sustainable to eat than others?

Our oceans are not able to sustain the appetite of our growing global population at our current level of consumption and with our current fishing practices. By eating less or eliminating meat and fish from our diets, and choosing more plant-based meals, we can improve the health of the oceans and the planet.

For those who choose to eat fish, the most important thing is to avoid species already threatened by overfishing, like bluefin tuna. Small-scale fishing with gear that’s friendly to marine mammals is preferable, but we need improve the management of fisheries worldwide to drastically reduce bycatch and overfishing before any type of fish can be considered a truly sustainable source of protein.

 

Q: What about food waste?

As much as 40 percent of food produced in the United States is thrown away. That’s not only a waste of the food itself and the money spent on it, but it’s also a waste of the land, water, fuel, packaging and other resources that went into producing the food in the first place. And as food decomposes, it releases methane, which directly contributes to climate change.

 

There are a number of ways to address food waste, from educating consumers to increasing opportunities to donate excess food and expanding composting programs. However, one of the greatest sources of agricultural waste is meat production. More than half of the grain grown in the United States is fed to livestock, and nearly half of the water used goes toward raising animals for food. Plant protein uses significantly less land, water and fossil fuels than animal protein, so by choosing to reduce your meat consumption, you’re already a step ahead in reducing your overall food waste.

 

Q: How will I get enough protein if I start eating more meatless meals?

A lot of people worry that they won’t get enough protein if they reduce their meat consumption.  But the average American eats almost twice the daily recommended intake of protein. Plus it’s easy to meet your daily protein needs from plant-based sources. Nuts, beans, seeds, tofu, tempeh and quinoa are all meatless sources of protein that are easy to prepare and easy on your budget. (Choose organic where possible.) Protein can even be found in vegetables, such as spinach (2.1 grams per 2 cups raw) and broccoli (8.1 grams per one cup chopped).

 

Q: How do I get started changing my diet?

Take the pledge to join the movement and commit to eating an Earth-friendly diet.

 

Check out our resources page to learn more and find recipes to help you get started.